Influencers and What They Are Influencing: A Critical Analysis

Influencers and What They Are Influencing: A Critical Analysis


In today's digital age, influencers have become prominent in shaping opinions, promoting products, and impacting various aspects of our lives. However, evaluating their influence and considering the potential implications is essential. This article examines influencers and their power, focusing on factors such as credibility, brand partnerships, addressing product issues, genuineness, impact on self-esteem, and the need for realistic expectations.

Resonating With Influencers:

Individuals may resonate with specific influencers based on shared interests, values, or aspirations. However, it's crucial to remain aware of the curated nature of their content and not mindlessly adopt their perspectives without thinking critically about their messaging. Influencers can help motivate and inspire but also leave remnants of self-doubt and internalization, which is not conducive to a positive relationship with anyone. 

Duration of Influence:

The influencer landscape has evolved rapidly over the past decade, with some influencers gaining prominence early on and others emerging more recently. The length of time an influencer has been active does not necessarily equate to credibility or authenticity. An influencer who has been around for a long time may know how to handle themselves better than someone less experienced, but they need to be more credible and more aware of issues within the social media world. 

The Credibility of Influencers:

While some influencers have built a trustworthy reputation through consistent and reliable content, others may need more credibility due to misleading practices, undisclosed sponsorships, or dubious product promotion. Researching and assessing an influencer's credibility before accepting their recommendations is important. Moreover, understand what the law says about advertising and promotion guidelines. If they violate these regulations by governing bodies, it can make you question what else they are willing to deviate from when their truth doesn't fit into the mold they are trying to create. 

Brand Partnerships:

Many influencers collaborate with brands to promote products or services. Understanding which brands back an influencer is crucial as it reflects their alignment with specific values, ethics, and quality standards. It is essential to scrutinize both the influencers and the brands they endorse. As a consumer, you should question whether the brands they are involved with share your values. If you are an inclusive person, however, the brand they endorse is not, you may be hurt by going against your beliefs simply because you did not know the whole story. 

Addressing Product Issues:

An influencer's credibility can be assessed by how they handle product issues. If they only provide overwhelmingly positive reviews and do not acknowledge potential flaws or address customer concerns, it raises questions about their objectivity and transparency. No company is perfect. We all make mistakes, bad calls and decisions that are misguided. However, a company willing to come forward and say it made a mistake and is working on correcting the issue is far more in tune with everyday life than one that ignores it or only addresses the problem to make it go away. 

Genuine Promotion:

Authenticity is critical when evaluating an influencer's content. Genuine influencers prioritize providing honest opinions and experiences, not solely focusing on sales or sponsorships. It is essential to distinguish between authentic recommendations and disguised advertisements. If your favourite influencer focuses on subtle product placement, it can be clear that they are not genuinely promoting the products and services. 

Relationship with Fans:

A crucial aspect of a successful influencer is their relationship with their audience. Influencers who genuinely care about their fans prioritize open communication, engagement, and feedback. It is crucial to support those who demonstrate a genuine interest in their followers. Some influencers can become defensive if they are called out on things they have done that were questionable. They may lash out at their fans, isolating them by calling those who remained silent true fans who they love. At the same time, those who chose not to follow something said mindlessly, haters—creating a problematic relationship for everyone involved. This can cause retaliation and unprovoked attacks while the influencer sits back and waits for everything to return to normal. 

Toxic Traits:

Unfortunately, some influencers exhibit toxic traits such as promoting unhealthy beauty standards, engaging in excessive materialism, or encouraging negative behaviours. Recognizing and distancing oneself from influencers who exhibit harmful characteristics that may negatively impact mental well-being is crucial. For example, it is okay for you to want a clean and perfect home that so many social media influencers promote, but your reality might fail to make that possible. Moreover, if an influencer makes you feel terrible about how you can live, it is best to move on from them. 

Impact on Self-esteem:

Influencers have the power to influence how we perceive ourselves and our self-worth. It's essential to know how their content affects our self-esteem and maintain a healthy perspective, recognizing that everyone has flaws and imperfections. In many aspects, influencers contribute to the ideals that perfection is the only way to live. If you do not have the perfect home, family, job, and so on, you are somehow less than. However, they fail to address real-life issues; whether financial, medical, or something else, many people are just doing their best. We turn to social media for guidance but often walk away with self-doubt and lower self-esteem, leading to more mental health issues and concerns. 

Realistic Expectations:

While influencers may appear flawless online, they are human beings who make mistakes. Placing them on an unrealistic pedestal can lead to disappointment and unrealistic expectations. It's crucial to maintain a balanced perspective. You may follow them with an appreciation of what they do, but to base your whole identity and life around them is unhealthy as it can cause you to lose touch with yourself and your values.


Influencers hold significant sway in today's digital landscape, but it's vital to approach their influence critically. Considering factors such as credibility, brand partnerships, genuineness, impact on self-esteem, and realistic expectations allows us to make informed decisions and engage with influencers in a healthier, more responsible manner. Remember that influencers are not infallible, and it is crucial to maintain a sense of perspective and individuality in the face of their influence.

Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.

New Arrivals